COMMENT: Let us hope Castle Mill has taught the city a lesson

The Oxford Times: COMMENT: Let us hope Castle Mill has taught the city a lesson COMMENT: Let us hope Castle Mill has taught the city a lesson

THE finding that there was no malpractice or wrongdoing by Oxford City Council over the Castle Mill development is not a surprise.

But before there is any popping of champagne corks, it was only a cynical minority who saw a determined conspiracy over the planning permission for these blocks that are so controversially visible on the Port Meadow skyline.

It was always the case that Oxford City Council mishandled the whole process badly, and that the modern-day planning process almost appears set up to keep the wider public at arm’s length over decisions.

The acceptance of a recommendation to set up an independent panel of planning and heritage experts to look at large-scale developments and chief executive Peter Sloman’s comments are an admission things went wrong. But it sticks in the craw that instead of expecting our council planning officers do their jobs properly, the city has to wheel in outside experts at the taxpayers’ expense to prevent bungling.

The whole issue around Castle Mill is that people felt hoodwinked because the application flew under most people’s radars, especially once a critical report about the impact on the skyline was deemed as no longer relevant and airbrushed out of the process.

A few years ago planning authorities were allowed to retract the extent they had to make people in the wider area aware of applications. We warned then this was highly unsatisfactory, and this may well have played a part in why the stink over Castle Mill arose only when those blocks began to climb skywards, after permission had been granted.

The city council failed. Let’s hope it has learned its lesson.

Comments (4)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

9:18am Sat 14 Dec 13

Zaxharias Ziegla says...

Well, that's all OK then!
Well, that's all OK then! Zaxharias Ziegla

8:04pm Sat 14 Dec 13

Andrew:Oxford says...

It's not an "independent panel" if it's made up with the usual people who complain about everything...
It's not an "independent panel" if it's made up with the usual people who complain about everything... Andrew:Oxford

4:03am Sun 15 Dec 13

East Oxford Web Watcher says...

Andrew:Oxford wrote:
It's not an "independent panel" if it's made up with the usual people who complain about everything...
and also what are the council supposed to do yo make the complainers aware of every planning application so that it does not "go under the radar". Take out front page ads in the national press, put it on Sky news, or maybe send every household a letter. As you said you can never satisfy the vocal minority
[quote][p][bold]Andrew:Oxford[/bold] wrote: It's not an "independent panel" if it's made up with the usual people who complain about everything...[/p][/quote]and also what are the council supposed to do yo make the complainers aware of every planning application so that it does not "go under the radar". Take out front page ads in the national press, put it on Sky news, or maybe send every household a letter. As you said you can never satisfy the vocal minority East Oxford Web Watcher

5:55pm Sun 15 Dec 13

Andrew:Oxford says...

East Oxford Web Watcher wrote:
Andrew:Oxford wrote:
It's not an "independent panel" if it's made up with the usual people who complain about everything...
and also what are the council supposed to do yo make the complainers aware of every planning application so that it does not "go under the radar". Take out front page ads in the national press, put it on Sky news, or maybe send every household a letter. As you said you can never satisfy the vocal minority
Well, Oxford City Council already have an automated email system that can be loaded up with 10 or so postcodes - and they'll automatically let you know if there has been an application nearby.

Probably not "Victorian" enough...
[quote][p][bold]East Oxford Web Watcher[/bold] wrote: [quote][p][bold]Andrew:Oxford[/bold] wrote: It's not an "independent panel" if it's made up with the usual people who complain about everything...[/p][/quote]and also what are the council supposed to do yo make the complainers aware of every planning application so that it does not "go under the radar". Take out front page ads in the national press, put it on Sky news, or maybe send every household a letter. As you said you can never satisfy the vocal minority[/p][/quote]Well, Oxford City Council already have an automated email system that can be loaded up with 10 or so postcodes - and they'll automatically let you know if there has been an application nearby. Probably not "Victorian" enough... Andrew:Oxford

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree