Frustration over court sentence on thief

Frustration over court sentence on thief

Luke Franklin with his mother Sandy and poodle Mitzy

Peter Gaughan

First published in News by

A TEENAGER who hurdled five fences as he chased a burglar out of his house has expressed his annoyance after the serial thief avoided jail.

Seventeen-year-old Luke Franklin returned home from college one afternoon last month to find his mum confronting Peter Gaughan at their home in Kennington Road, Kennington.

The 25-year-old intruder had taken the keys to Luke’s Honda Civic and had left it running in the drive stuffed with the family’s 42in television, a new laptop and eight-month-old miniature poodle Mitzy.

Luke, a keen runner and footballer, gave chase over fences and through brambles before Gaughan, of Herschel Crescent, Littlemore, jumped on to railway tracks behind the house.

Moments later, and having heard about the incident on his radio, Pcso Stephen Hall, who was cycling by the River Thames at Sandford, spotted the burglar stripped to the waist lying on the riverbank.

Gaughan made an attempt to swim to freedom, but was caught and arrested.

He was sentenced at Oxford Crown Court on Monday, having earlier admitted one charge of burglary and an attempted burglary on the same day in Upper Road, Kennington.

Judge Anthony King gave Gaughan, whose previous convictions include 20 theft offences since 2000, an 11-month jail term, suspended for two years.

Related links

He was also ordered to do 200 hours unpaid work, take part in a restorative justice programme and be under supervision for 12 months. Speaking after the sentence, Luke Franklin said: “I am a bit annoyed about it, to be honest.

“I am doing public service at college so we’ve learned about the crown court and sentences.

“I have seen some sentences for robbery of three or four years, so I thought he would get more than 11 months suspended.”

Following Gaughan’s arrest police managed to rescue some of the Franklins’ stolen items from the river, including two old mobile phones and collection of coins.

However, an Armani watch and two month-old mobile phones have never been returned.

Luke said officers had informed him of Gaughan’s obligation to meet the family as part of a restorative justice programme, but his parents would have to decide whether to agree to it.

He added: “Overall, I am annoyed about the time he has been given, but on the positive side if he does not learn from this and reoffends then it will be a lot more serious.”

  • What do you think? Does the punishment fit the crime? Have your say at oxfordmail.co.uk

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

1:00pm Wed 16 Jun 10

LadyPenelope says...

"He added: “Overall, I am annoyed about the time he has been given, but on the positive side if he does not learn from this and reoffends then it will be a lot more serious.” "

But he quite clearly HAS NOT taken on board anything given his past; it's not like it was a first offence! If he EVER gets caught again, I hope he gets a VERY long sentence...
"He added: “Overall, I am annoyed about the time he has been given, but on the positive side if he does not learn from this and reoffends then it will be a lot more serious.” " But he quite clearly HAS NOT taken on board anything given his past; it's not like it was a first offence! If he EVER gets caught again, I hope he gets a VERY long sentence... LadyPenelope
  • Score: 0

2:47pm Wed 16 Jun 10

newcy says...

Have any members of the police force recently got a new 42-inch tv -or at least two new mobile 'phones? Perhaps that may help to explain the leniency of the punishment... It does seem that burglary, mugging and physical assault are all gold-star offences -more likely to earn a reward than a punishment for the offender. No wonder Oxfordshire has such problems with these crimes. And don't even begin to bleat on about drug-dependency being a major reason for these crimes -that seems to just be a carte-blanche to commit any crimes a 'user' wishes, and the only one who suffers at all is their victim.
Have any members of the police force recently got a new 42-inch tv -or at least two new mobile 'phones? Perhaps that may help to explain the leniency of the punishment... It does seem that burglary, mugging and physical assault are all gold-star offences -more likely to earn a reward than a punishment for the offender. No wonder Oxfordshire has such problems with these crimes. And don't even begin to bleat on about drug-dependency being a major reason for these crimes -that seems to just be a carte-blanche to commit any crimes a 'user' wishes, and the only one who suffers at all is their victim. newcy
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree