Villagers oppose home designed like an "alien spaceship"

Opponents of the plan, include, front, from left, David Palmer, Abigail Boisot with 16-month-old Maisie Butcher, Matthew Butcher, and, behind, members of Save Wincote Action Group. Opponents of the plan, include, front, from left, David Palmer, Abigail Boisot with 16-month-old Maisie Butcher, Matthew Butcher, and, behind, members of Save Wincote Action Group.

PLANS to partially demolish an old stone house and replace it with a “contemporary” building using glass and timber have upset villagers.

The house, named Wincote, was built in Steeple Aston, near Bicester, in 1840.

Now plans have been submitted to extend the house, with a bold design by architect Henry Squire.

Mr Squire, whose family has owned Wincote since the 1970s, said: “We have put an enormous amount of love and care into drawing up these plans.”

But villager David Palmer opposes the scehme and has set up a Save Wincote group.

Mr Palmer lived in the house as a tenant before moving to another home in the village.

He said: “It’s a quiet village full of stone cottages. This design is like an alien spaceship.”

Abigail Boisot moved in next door to Wincote only a week before the planning notice appeared on a post outside the property. She said: “We are in a state of shock. Our searches hadn’t shown anything. This building would be gargantuan.”

She added: “We would have a 12-place car park outside our window and our garden would overlook the back of their house instead of orchards.”

Mr Squire, a director of Squire and Partners, responsible for the controversial Chelsea Barracks redevelopment in London, said the building would be a six-bedroom family home. He said the car park was included to avoid parking in the lane.

Related links

He said he was aware of the concerns and would come back with revised ideas, but insisted any new plans would “have a contemporary feel”.

Previous occupants of the existing four-bedroom house include the Marquess of Blandford and broadcaster Anne Robinson.

l A public meeting about the plans is being held at Steeple Aston village hall on Tuesday at 7.30pm.

Comments(8)

hagar1 says...
4:24pm Thu 14 Jul 11

Here we go again!! Not in my back yard!

Can we see the plans - it would be nice to have a look at what the future holds for us in terms of architecture or do we have to look at little cottages made of stone for the rest of our lives!

Lord Peter Macvay says...
4:32pm Thu 14 Jul 11

COMEDIAN Rowan Atkinson won permission to build his controversial ultra-modern dream countryside home — despite council officers recommending the plan be turned down.
The Mr Bean and Blackadder star will now demolish a 1930s country house near Ipsden and replace it with a five-bedroomed home in glass and bright white steel. If you look at this story in the archives it may give you an idae.

FastJag says...
10:36pm Thu 14 Jul 11

We are local people, trying to protect historic assets and countryside: not just for ourselves, but for the thousands of ramblers, dog walkers, children, horse riders and cyclists that enjoy this area, as part of an Oxford Circular Walk. We have a shared heritage, which we cherish, and are determined to protect for now - and for future generations.

This site affects what is arguably the most idyllic part of Steeple Aston - itself one of the most beautiful villages in the Cherwell Valley. It also impacts on the Grade II* Heritage Landscape created by William Kent in 1740, around Rousham House and the Rousham Eyecatcher.

If we can't defend a designated heritage asset inside an historic conservation area, what hope is there for protecting anything?

You can learn more about this, including maps and plans, plus many detailed arguments, by visiting:

http://savewincote.o
rg

Please join with us to help protect our village heritage.

Severian says...
6:46am Fri 15 Jul 11

I adore modern architecture and grand designs, but this is just horrid! The scale is far too large for the setting, and the design is so fussy it looks like a 6th former doodled on graph paper.
But I have no doubt our planners will just wave it through - sorry. They've shown in Bicester that having lots of money and preposterous ideas is what gets you approval.

hagar1 says...
1:38pm Fri 15 Jul 11

Fastjag - I love your 'sincerity', help us protect our village heritage. My heart bleeds.

The objections on the website are laughable, nimbyism at its best!

I hope he gets planning just so i can listen to rose cottage brigade bleet on some more.

rayroad says...
2:04pm Fri 15 Jul 11

You are welcome to live in modern architecture if you want but it would be nice if there were some cottages left for those who wish to live in them (and by the way I live on a 60's housing estate, not anywhere near Steeple Aston).

Fine if people want to experiment with modern architecture, but there really is no need to do it in the middle of a conservation area. Why not sell the existing house to someone who will appreciate it and put your innovative architecture somewhere more suitable..hey why not make it part of the eco-town ?

Frankly I don't see anything particularly innovative in the design anyway

funny how this development has a separate garden for each bedroom hmm surely they are not planning to convert it to holiday flats later on once past the first hurdle or am I being cynical...

West Oxon Webwatcher says...
2:20pm Fri 15 Jul 11

The comparison with Rowan Atkinson's project does not appear to be valid. R.A.'s development was, I believe, not immediately overlooked by neighbouring homes although I think from the photos it is a prominent site. From this report it appears that neighbours would be much closer to this development and it could well be detrimental to their privacy if, as is suggested, it is close to the property boundary and devalues their home.

Severian says...
12:16pm Sat 16 Jul 11

Rayroad - there will be absolutely NO architectural merit in the design of the "eco-town", which will simply be a lot of wooden clad boxes crammed into as small a space as possible, and sold at vastly inflated prices.
I take the point about the design - it is almost industrial if this is one home, but beautifully scaled if you want to later split it into 4 houses. Like you I am a cynic about planning matters.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree