'Large families cannot cope with small bins' (From The Oxford Times)
When It Happens Panel Get involved: send your photos, videos, news & views by texting 'OXFORD NEWS' to 80360 or email
'Large families cannot cope with small bins'
2:00pm Saturday 16th June 2012 in Bicester By Sam McGregor, covering Bicester. Call me on 01869 250197
A FAMILY of nine has criticised council plans to replace its rubbish bin with one almost half its size.
Paul and Amanda Craig, 45 and 42 respectively, live with their seven children, aged from four to 18, in Leach Road, Bicester.
Cherwell District Council began phasing in smaller bins last year to force people to increase the amount they recycle. The family’s bin holds about 600 litres of rubbish but the new one will only hold 360 litres.
They also recycle cardboard, tins and plastics in two 240-litre blue bins, and food and garden waste in a brown bin.
Mr Craig is concerned excess waste will build up at their house or they will have to pay for extra collections.
He said: “As kids get older the rubbish they are consuming increases. If the council doesn’t take all of the rubbish it will charge us to collect the excess.
“It’s not just us affected, it’s all large families.”
The couple, who are both registered blind, have been told they can have a third blue bin to help them recycle more.
But Mr Craig is urging other large families to make a joint stand and is considering launching a petition.
He said: “This is a house of nine of us and they want to give us a smaller bin.
“It will still be collected fortnightly basis but we won’t cope with that. It leaves us with two options – to take the council to court or go to a private waste management company.
“They said it was a change of policy last April and the bigger bins will be removed from houses that need them, and given to blocks of flats.
“The council said try to recycle more and we’ll give you another blue bin, but what about storage for all these bins?
“The back garden is full as it is, we’ve got four bins – where are the children going to play?”
Councils across the country are introducing smaller bins as way of improving recycling rates. This helps cut down on the amount of waste they send to landfill, which can lead to government charges if too much is dumped.
Nigel Morris, Cherwell’s lead member for clean and green, said: “We are in the process of assessing the needs of everyone with one of our larger green bins.
“Most are able to recycle more, meaning they do not need a larger bin, but very large families with babies or younger children still in nappies do need the extra space. Where we are removing the larger green bins, we might be able to offer families greater recycling capacity.”
Changes were introduced following the introduction of the food waste recycling. Households that had the larger bins, or applied for them, had their situations reviewed every three years.
Comments(7)
Grumpy09
says...
2:37pm Sat 16 Jun 12
If thats the case they shouldnt need any bins at all?!
Dilligaf2010
says...
3:38pm Sat 16 Jun 12
Grumpy09 wrote:LOL ;)
"As kids get older the rubbish they are consuming increases."
If thats the case they shouldnt need any bins at all?!
EMBOX1
says...
5:47pm Sat 16 Jun 12
A family of nine is massive, and frankly unacceptable unless you are earning serious money to pay for them all. I suspect, with these parents both blind, they didn't win the lottery and thus you and I are paying for their upkeep.
It's not fair on the rest of us.
oxford85
says...
1:53am Mon 18 Jun 12
snert
says...
10:40am Mon 18 Jun 12
That said, the story is about the bins... In my house there are two adults and no kids. There is a dog but he doesn't produce a lot of household waste.
Every two weeks my green bin is emptied. Generally there is one, sometimes two swingbin liners in it so it is rarely more than a quarter full even after two weeks. Both my partner and I work from home most of the time and still we don't produce that much rubbish in the green bin. If I scaled up that rubbish to 9 people I suspect my large green bin may well be full after two weeks, possibly even overflowing but not by much.
Now the blue bin is full to the brim every two weeks. Sometimes I have to get in it and stamp it down there is so much recyclable waste. I bought one of the blue bins because the boxes are simply not large enough and that is for two people. Scaling this up, for 9 people I would need at least 4 or 5 large blue bins for recyclable rubbish every two weeks. Now the family is saying they recycle and they have the two boxes. Well, they clearly don't recycle everything as a family of 9 over a two week period only fill the two blue boxes.
Smaller green bins will pressure people into recycling more which is a good thing. However, people still seem to need educating on what can be recycled. If it is paper, card, metal or plastic it goes in the recycle bin. Glass goes into my own recycle bin which I take to the bottle banks when it is full.
Recycling in Oxfordshire couldn't really be easier. The family needs to reassess how much they recycle and fork out for a large blue bin or two. I'd agree that a half size green bin is not big enough for them though. That is a bit stupid of the council.
steve1955
says...
9:48pm Sat 30 Jun 12
Dilligaf2010 says...
2:23pm Sat 16 Jun 12
......wow, that's got to be a small back garden.
There are too many people who don't recycle all they can, I'm not saying this family is one of them, but if reducing the size of the green bins encourages more recycling, it can only be a good thing.
I live in a block, and one of my neighbours is too lazy to walk to the recycling bins, if I was a bit bigger I'd put him in a green bin, because his actions aren't helping anyone.