Order to justify taxi CCTV plan (From The Oxford Times)
When It Happens Panel Get involved: send your photos, videos, news & views by texting 'OXFORD NEWS' to 80360 or email
Order to justify taxi CCTV plan
10:30am Tuesday 24th April 2012 in Oxford
By Oliver Evans, covering Banbury. Call me on 01865 425271
Taxi driver Khalil Ahmed
OXFORD City Council has been told to justify its plan for recording conversations in taxis in a move that may take the controversial scheme closer to being ruled a breach of privacy.
The Information Commissioner’s Office has served a preliminary enforcement notice on the council over its plans to make all Hackney cabs and private hire taxis it licenses install a sound and video recording system.
The ICO says the compulsory scheme may not comply with the Data Protection Act and has asked the council to submit a written response proving otherwise.
If the commissioner’s office is not satisfied with the council’s response, it can issue an enforcement notice, demanding that the plan is scrapped.
Failure to comply is a criminal offence.
The council wants all new cabs to have the £460 cameras, with the existing 665 vehicles fitted by April 2015.
It has offered to pay £100 towards the cost of each recording system.
The council argues cameras will protect drivers from assaults and allegations by passengers.
It says footage would only be reviewed on request.
The watchdog contacted the council after the Oxford Mail reported on the proposals in November last year.
The ICO’s CCTV code of practice says: “CCTV must not be used to record conversations between members of the public, as this is highly intrusive.”
The scheme was due to start on April 1 but was put on hold by the council because of the watchdog’s intervention.
ICO spokesman Greg Jones said: “The notice relates to our concerns that the scheme may not be compliant with the requirements of the Data Protection Act.”
The Act’s principles include the demand that collection of information should be “not excessive”.
The council has until early next month to respond.
Spokesman Annette Cunningham said: “As a public body, it is right that the council should reflect on the concerns expressed. The scheme has been suspended pending that reconsideration.”
Nick Pickles, director of privacy campaign group Big Brother Watch, said: “It’s time for the plan to be dropped.”
Private hire driver Khalil Ahmed – who collected 273 signatures on a petition against the plan – said: “It’s very positive news.
“We have always argued against the legality of it. It is futile and unnecessary and a waste of ratepayers’ money.”
Comments(12)
ColSilver
says...
12:44pm Tue 24 Apr 12
rect.gov.uk/petition
s/31860
Oxford taxpayer
says...
2:30pm Tue 24 Apr 12
Apu Nahasapeemapetilon
says...
3:16pm Tue 24 Apr 12
Oxford taxpayer wrote:Although they cannot vote, you will find that the Taxi driving Labour councillors are against it, Taxi Licensing are a law unto themselves, and not guided by party politics. Then we have the ludicrous statement that the council will pay £100 towards it, no they won't we will out of our licence fees that could go to providing a rank at Carfax and by Debenhams during the day as that is where people want taxis not 200 yards away in the middle of a 4 lane busy road.Now that buses have cut the number of services there is no reason that there is not room for ranks in these two places.
ox-cabby: As a user of taxis I agree with you. Labour will not get my vote next month.
John Lamb
says...
4:16pm Tue 24 Apr 12
Oxford taxpayer
says...
4:29pm Tue 24 Apr 12
Apu Nahasapeemapetilon
says...
4:59pm Tue 24 Apr 12
Oxford taxpayer
says...
5:54pm Tue 24 Apr 12
ox-cabby
says...
7:03pm Tue 24 Apr 12
Exactly that!
davyboy
says...
7:38am Wed 25 Apr 12
John Lamb
says...
8:35pm Wed 25 Apr 12
Apu Nahasapeemapetilon wrote:I'll get back to you when your english improves.
can't do too much detail as going to work for evening rush i hope. But John how does CCTV spying on my family make your journey safer if only when meter turned on maybe ok. John how many taxi journeys you take a week and how many problems you have in the past, this important because you know about my trade more than me if you tell us all how many problem for not having CCTV then we know if your comment true or you not like taxi driver. Oxford Taxpayer colin cook is in no way the speaker for Taxi driver who is councillor if you live in area for councillor taxi driver ask him, not Mr Cook he speaks only for himself.
Oh see, there's one example; when confusion with language barriers occurs.
UKCabman
says...
5:11pm Wed 16 May 12
ox-cabby says...
11:18am Tue 24 Apr 12
Ok, now make space for the ''taxi drivers got something to hide'' brigade!