'Bizarre' breaches of Asbo end in jail (From The Oxford Times)
When It Happens Panel Get involved: send your photos, videos, news & views by texting 'OXFORD NEWS' to 80360 or email
'Bizarre' breaches of Asbo end in jail
5:50pm Tuesday 1st May 2012 in Oxford By Thom Airs
Stuart McGhie
A MAN who has spent a decade pinning banknotes to park benches for schoolgirls to pick up has been jailed once more.
Stuart McGhie was first given an Antisocial Behaviour Order (Asbo) in 2002 after a spate of seven incidents in which he left notes and messages to children around Oxford.
The order prohibited the 42-year-old from “seeking contact or communication” with under-18s and “allowing banknotes to fall on surfaces”.
But he has since admitted breaching the Asbo 18 times and was back at Oxford Crown Court on Friday for the latest offences, which took place on October 10.
Prosecutor Jonathan Stone said McGhie, who was jailed for 15 months in October 2010, left a note on a bench at a bus stop near the Jolly Postboys pub, close to Florence Park, Oxford.
The note, which read ‘Text for cash’ and gave a mobile number, was picked up at 12.30pm by a 12-year-old schoolgirl who sent a message to the number.
She was then instructed by McGhie, of Church Cowley Road, Oxford, to go to two benches in Florence Park which each had a single £10 note taped to them.
Mr Stone said the girl had repeated contact with McGhie through texts and calls before the police were informed by her parents.
He added: “It is an unusual case because the Asbo was back in 2002. There have been numerous breaches of that order, but things have never become ‘hands on’.
“I think the fear with this defendant has always been what might happen, but what might happen hasn’t happened in the previous 10 years.”
He continued: “It’s a case that has a sinister side to it as well as young children thinking this is all a bit of a joke.”
Jennifer Edwards, defending, said: “There’s no overt record of any distress that this child has suffered.
“She does say ‘I have never met the male and I didn’t know who he is, he has never given me a name’.
“Since July 2002 the only offences he has committed are breaches of the Asbo.
“This Asbo is indefinite and, of course, the worry has always been – and the courts have tried to address this – how can we stop him behaving in this way?
“There’s no good putting him on the sex offender programme because it simply doesn’t match his offending.”
Recorder Niall Quinn jailed McGhie for two and a half years and told him: “You’re 42 years of age and for 10 years you have been engaged in a course of bizarre, sinister conduct towards young girls around the age of 12 and 14.
“I’m presented with a tension – doing what might be best for you and what might be best for the young female population of Oxford and elsewhere.”
Comments(6)
Lord Palmerstone
says...
8:57pm Tue 1 May 12
Milkbutnosugarplease
says...
9:39pm Tue 1 May 12
John Lamb
says...
9:21am Wed 2 May 12
Lord Palmerstone wrote:Less Thoughtcrime and more like grooming Your Lordship. I'm glad the bench saw it that way too. I didn't expect sympathy for a man with a penchant for underage girls on here.
No doubt he may be. But it is Thoughtcrime isn't it? I think I'd sooner see burglars locked up for an adequate time than this peculiar fellow, who hasn't broken in on anyone's home. Moreover I'd struggle to comprehend how the Recorder knew that Mr. Magoo could guarantee that a dull 12 year old would pick up the note as opposed to a bright one, or indeed a Yardie.
oxfordboy00
says...
12:57pm Wed 2 May 12
Milkbutnosugarplease wrote:he cant afford a new scarf as all his bank notes are stuck to park benches and trees around oxford,
He's had the same scarf every time his photo appears.
LORD PETER MACVEY 0X2 6EG
says...
10:39pm Fri 4 May 12
John Lamb wrote:No grooming involved, just a penchant for giving money away, much better than those that seek to take it away. The fact that there is no mention of sexual offences at all, suggests that your accusation is well out of order, strange he may be, but a paedo, not.
Lord Palmerstone wrote:Less Thoughtcrime and more like grooming Your Lordship. I'm glad the bench saw it that way too. I didn't expect sympathy for a man with a penchant for underage girls on here.
No doubt he may be. But it is Thoughtcrime isn't it? I think I'd sooner see burglars locked up for an adequate time than this peculiar fellow, who hasn't broken in on anyone's home. Moreover I'd struggle to comprehend how the Recorder knew that Mr. Magoo could guarantee that a dull 12 year old would pick up the note as opposed to a bright one, or indeed a Yardie.
lightson says...
8:26pm Tue 1 May 12